I can now say that I've tried everything that came in the 4wk variety pack (except the bars - I'm only having 1 per week), and the Banana is the ONLY flavor I absolutely cannot stand in pudding or shake form.
Here's my list (yeah... I make a lot of lists lol)
Vanilla Shake - good
Strawberry Shake - good
Banana Shake - EW
Orange Shake - ok/good
Chocolate shake - ok
Hot Chocolate - ok
Chai - ok - too spicy, needed extra water
Cappucino - FABULOUS
Chili - Good w/garlic, onion & chili powder + 2tbls rotel
Minestrone - ok
Chicken & Rice - YUMMY!
Cream of Tomato - Great w/garlic powder, salt & a touch of pickle juice
Chicken noodle - good
Cream of Broccoli - Ok, a little thin
Chocolate Pudding - YUM!
Banana Pudding - EW
Peach Oatmeal - good
Apple Cinnamon Oatmeal - ok, kind of bland
French Vanilla Berry - ok, bland
Maple & Brown Sugar - bland
Oatmeal Raisin Bar - Good
Again, I haven't tried any of the other bars yet as I'm restricting them to once a week, but that covers all of the items I have tasted. Of course, everyones taste varies & there are people who love the banana but hate the vanilla or something else I liked. So, I guess I'd suggest ordering the 4wk variety pack (with 1wk free) to get a fell for most of the foods available!
Also, I'm still going to give the banana another shot, playing with extracts & spices to see if I can mask the faux banana taste